Cura/cura/Settings/CuraContainerRegistry.py

# Copyright (c) 2019 Ultimaker B.V.
# Cura is released under the terms of the LGPLv3 or higher.

import os
import re
import configparser

from typing import Any, cast, Dict, Optional, List, Union
from PyQt5.QtWidgets import QMessageBox

from UM.Decorators import override
from UM.Settings.ContainerFormatError import ContainerFormatError
from UM.Settings.Interfaces import ContainerInterface
from UM.Settings.ContainerRegistry import ContainerRegistry
from UM.Settings.ContainerStack import ContainerStack
from UM.Settings.InstanceContainer import InstanceContainer
from UM.Settings.SettingInstance import SettingInstance
from UM.Application import Application
from UM.Logger import Logger
from UM.Message import Message
from UM.Platform import Platform
from UM.PluginRegistry import PluginRegistry  # For getting the possible profile writers to write with.
from UM.Resources import Resources
from UM.Util import parseBool
from cura.ReaderWriters.ProfileWriter import ProfileWriter

from . import ExtruderStack
from . import GlobalStack

import cura.CuraApplication
from cura.Settings.cura_empty_instance_containers import empty_quality_container
from cura.Machines.ContainerTree import ContainerTree
from cura.ReaderWriters.ProfileReader import NoProfileException, ProfileReader

from UM.i18n import i18nCatalog
catalog = i18nCatalog("cura")


class CuraContainerRegistry(ContainerRegistry):
    def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
        super().__init__(*args, **kwargs)

        # We don't have all the machines loaded in the beginning, so in order to add the missing extruder stack
        # for single extrusion machines, we subscribe to the containerAdded signal, and whenever a global stack
        # is added, we check to see if an extruder stack needs to be added.
        self.containerAdded.connect(self._onContainerAdded)

    ##  Overridden from ContainerRegistry
    #
    #   Adds a container to the registry.
    #
    #   This will also try to convert a ContainerStack to either Extruder or
    #   Global stack based on metadata information.
    @override(ContainerRegistry)
    def addContainer(self, container: ContainerInterface) -> None:
        # Note: Intentional check with type() because we want to ignore subclasses
        if type(container) == ContainerStack:
            container = self._convertContainerStack(cast(ContainerStack, container))

        if isinstance(container, InstanceContainer) and type(container) != type(self.getEmptyInstanceContainer()):
            # Check against setting version of the definition.
            required_setting_version = cura.CuraApplication.CuraApplication.SettingVersion
            actual_setting_version = int(container.getMetaDataEntry("setting_version", default = 0))
            if required_setting_version != actual_setting_version:
                Logger.log("w", "Instance container {container_id} is outdated. Its setting version is {actual_setting_version} but it should be {required_setting_version}.".format(container_id = container.getId(), actual_setting_version = actual_setting_version, required_setting_version = required_setting_version))
                return  # Don't add.

        super().addContainer(container)

    ##  Create a name that is not empty and unique
    #   \param container_type \type{string} Type of the container (machine, quality, ...)
    #   \param current_name \type{} Current name of the container, which may be an acceptable option
    #   \param new_name \type{string} Base name, which may not be unique
    #   \param fallback_name \type{string} Name to use when (stripped) new_name is empty
    #   \return \type{string} Name that is unique for the specified type and name/id
    def createUniqueName(self, container_type: str, current_name: str, new_name: str, fallback_name: str) -> str:
        new_name = new_name.strip()
        num_check = re.compile(r"(.*?)\s*#\d+$").match(new_name)
        if num_check:
            new_name = num_check.group(1)
        if new_name == "":
            new_name = fallback_name

        unique_name = new_name
        i = 1
        # In case we are renaming, the current name of the container is also a valid end-result
        while self._containerExists(container_type, unique_name) and unique_name != current_name:
            i += 1
            unique_name = "%s #%d" % (new_name, i)

        return unique_name

    ##  Check if a container with of a certain type and a certain name or id exists
    #   Both the id and the name are checked, because they may not be the same and it is better if they are both unique
    #   \param container_type \type{string} Type of the container (machine, quality, ...)
    #   \param container_name \type{string} Name to check
    def _containerExists(self, container_type: str, container_name: str):
        container_class = ContainerStack if container_type == "machine" else InstanceContainer

        return self.findContainersMetadata(container_type = container_class, id = container_name, type = container_type, ignore_case = True) or \
                self.findContainersMetadata(container_type = container_class, name = container_name, type = container_type)

    ##  Exports an profile to a file
    #
    #   \param container_list \type{list} the containers to export. This is not
    #   necessarily in any order!
    #   \param file_name \type{str} the full path and filename to export to.
    #   \param file_type \type{str} the file type with the format "<description> (*.<extension>)"
    #   \return True if the export succeeded, false otherwise.
    def exportQualityProfile(self, container_list: List[InstanceContainer], file_name: str, file_type: str) -> bool:
        # Parse the fileType to deduce what plugin can save the file format.
        # fileType has the format "<description> (*.<extension>)"
        split = file_type.rfind(" (*.")  # Find where the description ends and the extension starts.
        if split < 0:  # Not found. Invalid format.
            Logger.log("e", "Invalid file format identifier %s", file_type)
            return False
        description = file_type[:split]
        extension = file_type[split + 4:-1]  # Leave out the " (*." and ")".
        if not file_name.endswith("." + extension):  # Auto-fill the extension if the user did not provide any.
            file_name += "." + extension

        # On Windows, QML FileDialog properly asks for overwrite confirm, but not on other platforms, so handle those ourself.
        if not Platform.isWindows():
            if os.path.exists(file_name):
                result = QMessageBox.question(None, catalog.i18nc("@title:window", "File Already Exists"),
                                              catalog.i18nc("@label Don't translate the XML tag <filename>!", "The file <filename>{0}</filename> already exists. Are you sure you want to overwrite it?").format(file_name))
                if result == QMessageBox.No:
                    return False

        profile_writer = self._findProfileWriter(extension, description)
        try:
            if profile_writer is None:
                raise Exception("Unable to find a profile writer")
            success = profile_writer.write(file_name, container_list)
        except Exception as e:
            Logger.log("e", "Failed to export profile to %s: %s", file_name, str(e))
            m = Message(catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename> or <message>!", "Failed to export profile to <filename>{0}</filename>: <message>{1}</message>", file_name, str(e)),
                        lifetime = 0,
                        title = catalog.i18nc("@info:title", "Error"))
            m.show()
            return False
        if not success:
            Logger.log("w", "Failed to export profile to %s: Writer plugin reported failure.", file_name)
            m = Message(catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tag <filename>!", "Failed to export profile to <filename>{0}</filename>: Writer plugin reported failure.", file_name),
                        lifetime = 0,
                        title = catalog.i18nc("@info:title", "Error"))
            m.show()
            return False
        m = Message(catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tag <filename>!", "Exported profile to <filename>{0}</filename>", file_name),
                    title = catalog.i18nc("@info:title", "Export succeeded"))
        m.show()
        return True

    ##  Gets the plugin object matching the criteria
    #   \param extension
    #   \param description
    #   \return The plugin object matching the given extension and description.
    def _findProfileWriter(self, extension: str, description: str) -> Optional[ProfileWriter]:
        plugin_registry = PluginRegistry.getInstance()
        for plugin_id, meta_data in self._getIOPlugins("profile_writer"):
            for supported_type in meta_data["profile_writer"]:  # All file types this plugin can supposedly write.
                supported_extension = supported_type.get("extension", None)
                if supported_extension == extension:  # This plugin supports a file type with the same extension.
                    supported_description = supported_type.get("description", None)
                    if supported_description == description:  # The description is also identical. Assume it's the same file type.
                        return cast(ProfileWriter, plugin_registry.getPluginObject(plugin_id))
        return None

    ##  Imports a profile from a file
    #
    #   \param file_name The full path and filename of the profile to import.
    #   \return Dict with a 'status' key containing the string 'ok' or 'error',
    #       and a 'message' key containing a message for the user.
    def importProfile(self, file_name: str) -> Dict[str, str]:
        Logger.log("d", "Attempting to import profile %s", file_name)
        if not file_name:
            return { "status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "Failed to import profile from <filename>{0}</filename>: {1}", file_name, "Invalid path")}

        global_stack = Application.getInstance().getGlobalContainerStack()
        if not global_stack:
            return {"status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "Can't import profile from <filename>{0}</filename> before a printer is added.", file_name)}
        container_tree = ContainerTree.getInstance()

        machine_extruders = []
        for position in sorted(global_stack.extruders):
            machine_extruders.append(global_stack.extruders[position])

        plugin_registry = PluginRegistry.getInstance()
        extension = file_name.split(".")[-1]

        for plugin_id, meta_data in self._getIOPlugins("profile_reader"):
            if meta_data["profile_reader"][0]["extension"] != extension:
                continue
            profile_reader = cast(ProfileReader, plugin_registry.getPluginObject(plugin_id))
            try:
                profile_or_list = profile_reader.read(file_name)  # Try to open the file with the profile reader.
            except NoProfileException:
                return { "status": "ok", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "No custom profile to import in file <filename>{0}</filename>", file_name)}
            except Exception as e:
                # Note that this will fail quickly. That is, if any profile reader throws an exception, it will stop reading. It will only continue reading if the reader returned None.
                Logger.log("e", "Failed to import profile from %s: %s while using profile reader. Got exception %s", file_name, profile_reader.getPluginId(), str(e))
                return { "status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "Failed to import profile from <filename>{0}</filename>:", file_name) + "\n<message>" + str(e) + "</message>"}

            if profile_or_list:
                # Ensure it is always a list of profiles
                if not isinstance(profile_or_list, list):
                    profile_or_list = [profile_or_list]

                # First check if this profile is suitable for this machine
                global_profile = None
                extruder_profiles = []
                if len(profile_or_list) == 1:
                    global_profile = profile_or_list[0]
                else:
                    for profile in profile_or_list:
                        if not profile.getMetaDataEntry("position"):
                            global_profile = profile
                        else:
                            extruder_profiles.append(profile)
                extruder_profiles = sorted(extruder_profiles, key = lambda x: int(x.getMetaDataEntry("position")))
                profile_or_list = [global_profile] + extruder_profiles

                if not global_profile:
                    Logger.log("e", "Incorrect profile [%s]. Could not find global profile", file_name)
                    return { "status": "error",
                             "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "This profile <filename>{0}</filename> contains incorrect data, could not import it.", file_name)}
                profile_definition = global_profile.getMetaDataEntry("definition")

                # Make sure we have a profile_definition in the file:
                if profile_definition is None:
                    break
                machine_definitions = self.findContainers(id = profile_definition)
                if not machine_definitions:
                    Logger.log("e", "Incorrect profile [%s]. Unknown machine type [%s]", file_name, profile_definition)
                    return {"status": "error",
                            "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status Don't translate the XML tags <filename>!", "This profile <filename>{0}</filename> contains incorrect data, could not import it.", file_name)
                            }
                machine_definition = machine_definitions[0]

                # Get the expected machine definition.
                # i.e.: We expect gcode for a UM2 Extended to be defined as normal UM2 gcode...
                has_machine_quality = parseBool(machine_definition.getMetaDataEntry("has_machine_quality", "false"))
                profile_definition = machine_definition.getMetaDataEntry("quality_definition", machine_definition.getId()) if has_machine_quality else "fdmprinter"
                expected_machine_definition = container_tree.machines[global_stack.definition.getId()].quality_definition

                # And check if the profile_definition matches either one (showing error if not):
                if profile_definition != expected_machine_definition:
                    Logger.log("d", "Profile {file_name} is for machine {profile_definition}, but the current active machine is {expected_machine_definition}. Changing profile's definition.".format(file_name = file_name, profile_definition = profile_definition, expected_machine_definition = expected_machine_definition))
                    global_profile.setMetaDataEntry("definition", expected_machine_definition)
                    for extruder_profile in extruder_profiles:
                        extruder_profile.setMetaDataEntry("definition", expected_machine_definition)

                quality_name = global_profile.getName()
                quality_type = global_profile.getMetaDataEntry("quality_type")

                name_seed = os.path.splitext(os.path.basename(file_name))[0]
                new_name = self.uniqueName(name_seed)

                # Ensure it is always a list of profiles
                if type(profile_or_list) is not list:
                    profile_or_list = [profile_or_list]

                # Make sure that there are also extruder stacks' quality_changes, not just one for the global stack
                if len(profile_or_list) == 1:
                    global_profile = profile_or_list[0]
                    extruder_profiles = []
                    for idx, extruder in enumerate(global_stack.extruders.values()):
                        profile_id = ContainerRegistry.getInstance().uniqueName(global_stack.getId() + "_extruder_" + str(idx + 1))
                        profile = InstanceContainer(profile_id)
                        profile.setName(quality_name)
                        profile.setMetaDataEntry("setting_version", cura.CuraApplication.CuraApplication.SettingVersion)
                        profile.setMetaDataEntry("type", "quality_changes")
                        profile.setMetaDataEntry("definition", expected_machine_definition)
                        profile.setMetaDataEntry("quality_type", quality_type)
                        profile.setDirty(True)
                        if idx == 0:
                            # Move all per-extruder settings to the first extruder's quality_changes
                            for qc_setting_key in global_profile.getAllKeys():
                                settable_per_extruder = global_stack.getProperty(qc_setting_key, "settable_per_extruder")
                                if settable_per_extruder:
                                    setting_value = global_profile.getProperty(qc_setting_key, "value")

                                    setting_definition = global_stack.getSettingDefinition(qc_setting_key)
                                    if setting_definition is not None:
                                        new_instance = SettingInstance(setting_definition, profile)
                                        new_instance.setProperty("value", setting_value)
                                        new_instance.resetState()  # Ensure that the state is not seen as a user state.
                                        profile.addInstance(new_instance)
                                        profile.setDirty(True)

                                    global_profile.removeInstance(qc_setting_key, postpone_emit = True)
                        extruder_profiles.append(profile)

                    for profile in extruder_profiles:
                        profile_or_list.append(profile)

                # Import all profiles
                for profile_index, profile in enumerate(profile_or_list):
                    if profile_index == 0:
                        # This is assumed to be the global profile
                        profile_id = (cast(ContainerInterface, global_stack.getBottom()).getId() + "_" + name_seed).lower().replace(" ", "_")

                    elif profile_index < len(machine_extruders) + 1:
                        # This is assumed to be an extruder profile
                        extruder_id = machine_extruders[profile_index - 1].definition.getId()
                        extruder_position = str(profile_index - 1)
                        if not profile.getMetaDataEntry("position"):
                            profile.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_position)
                        else:
                            profile.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_position)
                        profile_id = (extruder_id + "_" + name_seed).lower().replace(" ", "_")

                    else:  # More extruders in the imported file than in the machine.
                        continue  # Delete the additional profiles.

                    result = self._configureProfile(profile, profile_id, new_name, expected_machine_definition)
                    if result is not None:
                        return {"status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc(
                            "@info:status Don't translate the XML tag <filename>!",
                            "Failed to import profile from <filename>{0}</filename>:",
                            file_name) + " " + result}

                return {"status": "ok", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status", "Successfully imported profile {0}", profile_or_list[0].getName())}

            # This message is throw when the profile reader doesn't find any profile in the file
            return {"status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status", "File {0} does not contain any valid profile.", file_name)}

        # If it hasn't returned by now, none of the plugins loaded the profile successfully.
        return {"status": "error", "message": catalog.i18nc("@info:status", "Profile {0} has an unknown file type or is corrupted.", file_name)}

    @override(ContainerRegistry)
    def load(self) -> None:
        super().load()
        self._registerSingleExtrusionMachinesExtruderStacks()
        self._connectUpgradedExtruderStacksToMachines()

    ##  Check if the metadata for a container is okay before adding it.
    #
    #   This overrides the one from UM.Settings.ContainerRegistry because we
    #   also require that the setting_version is correct.
    @override(ContainerRegistry)
    def _isMetadataValid(self, metadata: Optional[Dict[str, Any]]) -> bool:
        if metadata is None:
            return False
        if "setting_version" not in metadata:
            return False
        try:
            if int(metadata["setting_version"]) != cura.CuraApplication.CuraApplication.SettingVersion:
                return False
        except ValueError: #Not parsable as int.
            return False
        return True

    ##  Update an imported profile to match the current machine configuration.
    #
    #   \param profile The profile to configure.
    #   \param id_seed The base ID for the profile. May be changed so it does not conflict with existing containers.
    #   \param new_name The new name for the profile.
    #
    #   \return None if configuring was successful or an error message if an error occurred.
    def _configureProfile(self, profile: InstanceContainer, id_seed: str, new_name: str, machine_definition_id: str) -> Optional[str]:
        profile.setDirty(True)  # Ensure the profiles are correctly saved

        new_id = self.createUniqueName("quality_changes", "", id_seed, catalog.i18nc("@label", "Custom profile"))
        profile.setMetaDataEntry("id", new_id)
        profile.setName(new_name)

        # Set the unique Id to the profile, so it's generating a new one even if the user imports the same profile
        # It also solves an issue with importing profiles from G-Codes
        profile.setMetaDataEntry("id", new_id)
        profile.setMetaDataEntry("definition", machine_definition_id)

        if "type" in profile.getMetaData():
            profile.setMetaDataEntry("type", "quality_changes")
        else:
            profile.setMetaDataEntry("type", "quality_changes")

        quality_type = profile.getMetaDataEntry("quality_type")
        if not quality_type:
            return catalog.i18nc("@info:status", "Profile is missing a quality type.")

        global_stack = Application.getInstance().getGlobalContainerStack()
        if global_stack is None:
            return None
        definition_id = ContainerTree.getInstance().machines[global_stack.definition.getId()].quality_definition
        profile.setDefinition(definition_id)

        # Check to make sure the imported profile actually makes sense in context of the current configuration.
        # This prevents issues where importing a "draft" profile for a machine without "draft" qualities would report as
        # successfully imported but then fail to show up.
        quality_group_dict = ContainerTree.getInstance().getCurrentQualityGroups()
        # "not_supported" profiles can be imported.
        if quality_type != empty_quality_container.getMetaDataEntry("quality_type") and quality_type not in quality_group_dict:
            return catalog.i18nc("@info:status", "Could not find a quality type {0} for the current configuration.", quality_type)

        ContainerRegistry.getInstance().addContainer(profile)

        return None

    @override(ContainerRegistry)
    def saveDirtyContainers(self) -> None:
        # Lock file for "more" atomically loading and saving to/from config dir.
        with self.lockFile():
            # Save base files first
            for instance in self.findDirtyContainers(container_type=InstanceContainer):
                if instance.getMetaDataEntry("removed"):
                    continue
                if instance.getId() == instance.getMetaData().get("base_file"):
                    self.saveContainer(instance)

            for instance in self.findDirtyContainers(container_type=InstanceContainer):
                if instance.getMetaDataEntry("removed"):
                    continue
                self.saveContainer(instance)

            for stack in self.findContainerStacks():
                self.saveContainer(stack)

    ##  Gets a list of profile writer plugins
    #   \return List of tuples of (plugin_id, meta_data).
    def _getIOPlugins(self, io_type):
        plugin_registry = PluginRegistry.getInstance()
        active_plugin_ids = plugin_registry.getActivePlugins()

        result = []
        for plugin_id in active_plugin_ids:
            meta_data = plugin_registry.getMetaData(plugin_id)
            if io_type in meta_data:
                result.append( (plugin_id, meta_data) )
        return result

    ##  Convert an "old-style" pure ContainerStack to either an Extruder or Global stack.
    def _convertContainerStack(self, container: ContainerStack) -> Union[ExtruderStack.ExtruderStack, GlobalStack.GlobalStack]:
        assert type(container) == ContainerStack

        container_type = container.getMetaDataEntry("type")
        if container_type not in ("extruder_train", "machine"):
            # It is not an extruder or machine, so do nothing with the stack
            return container

        Logger.log("d", "Converting ContainerStack {stack} to {type}", stack = container.getId(), type = container_type)

        if container_type == "extruder_train":
            new_stack = ExtruderStack.ExtruderStack(container.getId())
        else:
            new_stack = GlobalStack.GlobalStack(container.getId())

        container_contents = container.serialize()
        new_stack.deserialize(container_contents)

        # Delete the old configuration file so we do not get double stacks
        if os.path.isfile(container.getPath()):
            os.remove(container.getPath())

        return new_stack

    def _registerSingleExtrusionMachinesExtruderStacks(self) -> None:
        machines = self.findContainerStacks(type = "machine", machine_extruder_trains = {"0": "fdmextruder"})
        for machine in machines:
            extruder_stacks = self.findContainerStacks(type = "extruder_train", machine = machine.getId())
            if not extruder_stacks:
                self.addExtruderStackForSingleExtrusionMachine(machine, "fdmextruder")

    def _onContainerAdded(self, container: ContainerInterface) -> None:
        # We don't have all the machines loaded in the beginning, so in order to add the missing extruder stack
        # for single extrusion machines, we subscribe to the containerAdded signal, and whenever a global stack
        # is added, we check to see if an extruder stack needs to be added.
        if not isinstance(container, ContainerStack) or container.getMetaDataEntry("type") != "machine":
            return

        machine_extruder_trains = container.getMetaDataEntry("machine_extruder_trains")
        if machine_extruder_trains is not None and machine_extruder_trains != {"0": "fdmextruder"}:
            return

        extruder_stacks = self.findContainerStacks(type = "extruder_train", machine = container.getId())
        if not extruder_stacks:
            self.addExtruderStackForSingleExtrusionMachine(container, "fdmextruder")

    #
    # new_global_quality_changes is optional. It is only used in project loading for a scenario like this:
    #      - override the current machine
    #      - create new for custom quality profile
    # new_global_quality_changes is the new global quality changes container in this scenario.
    # create_new_ids indicates if new unique ids must be created
    #
    def addExtruderStackForSingleExtrusionMachine(self, machine, extruder_id, new_global_quality_changes = None, create_new_ids = True):
        new_extruder_id = extruder_id

        application = cura.CuraApplication.CuraApplication.getInstance()

        extruder_definitions = self.findDefinitionContainers(id = new_extruder_id)
        if not extruder_definitions:
            Logger.log("w", "Could not find definition containers for extruder %s", new_extruder_id)
            return

        extruder_definition = extruder_definitions[0]
        unique_name = self.uniqueName(machine.getName() + " " + new_extruder_id) if create_new_ids else machine.getName() + " " + new_extruder_id

        extruder_stack = ExtruderStack.ExtruderStack(unique_name)
        extruder_stack.setName(extruder_definition.getName())
        extruder_stack.setDefinition(extruder_definition)
        extruder_stack.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_definition.getMetaDataEntry("position"))

        # create a new definition_changes container for the extruder stack
        definition_changes_id = self.uniqueName(extruder_stack.getId() + "_settings") if create_new_ids else extruder_stack.getId() + "_settings"
        definition_changes_name = definition_changes_id
        definition_changes = InstanceContainer(definition_changes_id, parent = application)
        definition_changes.setName(definition_changes_name)
        definition_changes.setMetaDataEntry("setting_version", application.SettingVersion)
        definition_changes.setMetaDataEntry("type", "definition_changes")
        definition_changes.setMetaDataEntry("definition", extruder_definition.getId())

        # move definition_changes settings if exist
        for setting_key in definition_changes.getAllKeys():
            if machine.definition.getProperty(setting_key, "settable_per_extruder"):
                setting_value = machine.definitionChanges.getProperty(setting_key, "value")
                if setting_value is not None:
                    # move it to the extruder stack's definition_changes
                    setting_definition = machine.getSettingDefinition(setting_key)
                    new_instance = SettingInstance(setting_definition, definition_changes)
                    new_instance.setProperty("value", setting_value)
                    new_instance.resetState()  # Ensure that the state is not seen as a user state.
                    definition_changes.addInstance(new_instance)
                    definition_changes.setDirty(True)

                    machine.definitionChanges.removeInstance(setting_key, postpone_emit = True)

        self.addContainer(definition_changes)
        extruder_stack.setDefinitionChanges(definition_changes)

        # create empty user changes container otherwise
        user_container_id = self.uniqueName(extruder_stack.getId() + "_user") if create_new_ids else extruder_stack.getId() + "_user"
        user_container_name = user_container_id
        user_container = InstanceContainer(user_container_id, parent = application)
        user_container.setName(user_container_name)
        user_container.setMetaDataEntry("type", "user")
        user_container.setMetaDataEntry("machine", machine.getId())
        user_container.setMetaDataEntry("setting_version", application.SettingVersion)
        user_container.setDefinition(machine.definition.getId())
        user_container.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_stack.getMetaDataEntry("position"))

        if machine.userChanges:
            # For the newly created extruder stack, we need to move all "per-extruder" settings to the user changes
            # container to the extruder stack.
            for user_setting_key in machine.userChanges.getAllKeys():
                settable_per_extruder = machine.getProperty(user_setting_key, "settable_per_extruder")
                if settable_per_extruder:
                    setting_value = machine.getProperty(user_setting_key, "value")

                    setting_definition = machine.getSettingDefinition(user_setting_key)
                    new_instance = SettingInstance(setting_definition, definition_changes)
                    new_instance.setProperty("value", setting_value)
                    new_instance.resetState()  # Ensure that the state is not seen as a user state.
                    user_container.addInstance(new_instance)
                    user_container.setDirty(True)

                    machine.userChanges.removeInstance(user_setting_key, postpone_emit = True)

        self.addContainer(user_container)
        extruder_stack.setUserChanges(user_container)

        empty_variant = application.empty_variant_container
        empty_material = application.empty_material_container
        empty_quality = application.empty_quality_container

        if machine.variant.getId() not in ("empty", "empty_variant"):
            variant = machine.variant
        else:
            variant = empty_variant
        extruder_stack.variant = variant

        if machine.material.getId() not in ("empty", "empty_material"):
            material = machine.material
        else:
            material = empty_material
        extruder_stack.material = material

        if machine.quality.getId() not in ("empty", "empty_quality"):
            quality = machine.quality
        else:
            quality = empty_quality
        extruder_stack.quality = quality

        machine_quality_changes = machine.qualityChanges
        if new_global_quality_changes is not None:
            machine_quality_changes = new_global_quality_changes

        if machine_quality_changes.getId() not in ("empty", "empty_quality_changes"):
            extruder_quality_changes_container = self.findInstanceContainers(name = machine_quality_changes.getName(), extruder = extruder_id)
            if extruder_quality_changes_container:
                extruder_quality_changes_container = extruder_quality_changes_container[0]

                quality_changes_id = extruder_quality_changes_container.getId()
                extruder_stack.qualityChanges = self.findInstanceContainers(id = quality_changes_id)[0]
            else:
                # Some extruder quality_changes containers can be created at runtime as files in the qualities
                # folder. Those files won't be loaded in the registry immediately. So we also need to search
                # the folder to see if the quality_changes exists.
                extruder_quality_changes_container = self._findQualityChangesContainerInCuraFolder(machine_quality_changes.getName())
                if extruder_quality_changes_container:
                    quality_changes_id = extruder_quality_changes_container.getId()
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_definition.getMetaDataEntry("position"))
                    extruder_stack.qualityChanges = self.findInstanceContainers(id = quality_changes_id)[0]
                else:
                    # If we still cannot find a quality changes container for the extruder, create a new one
                    container_name = machine_quality_changes.getName()
                    container_id = self.uniqueName(extruder_stack.getId() + "_qc_" + container_name)
                    extruder_quality_changes_container = InstanceContainer(container_id, parent = application)
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setName(container_name)
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("type", "quality_changes")
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("setting_version", application.SettingVersion)
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("position", extruder_definition.getMetaDataEntry("position"))
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("quality_type", machine_quality_changes.getMetaDataEntry("quality_type"))
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setMetaDataEntry("intent_category", "default")  # Intent categories weren't a thing back then.
                    extruder_quality_changes_container.setDefinition(machine_quality_changes.getDefinition().getId())

                    self.addContainer(extruder_quality_changes_container)
                    extruder_stack.qualityChanges = extruder_quality_changes_container

            if not extruder_quality_changes_container:
                Logger.log("w", "Could not find quality_changes named [%s] for extruder [%s]",
                           machine_quality_changes.getName(), extruder_stack.getId())
            else:
                # Move all per-extruder settings to the extruder's quality changes
                for qc_setting_key in machine_quality_changes.getAllKeys():
                    settable_per_extruder = machine.getProperty(qc_setting_key, "settable_per_extruder")
                    if settable_per_extruder:
                        setting_value = machine_quality_changes.getProperty(qc_setting_key, "value")

                        setting_definition = machine.getSettingDefinition(qc_setting_key)
                        new_instance = SettingInstance(setting_definition, definition_changes)
                        new_instance.setProperty("value", setting_value)
                        new_instance.resetState()  # Ensure that the state is not seen as a user state.
                        extruder_quality_changes_container.addInstance(new_instance)
                        extruder_quality_changes_container.setDirty(True)

                        machine_quality_changes.removeInstance(qc_setting_key, postpone_emit=True)
        else:
            extruder_stack.qualityChanges = self.findInstanceContainers(id = "empty_quality_changes")[0]

        self.addContainer(extruder_stack)

        # Also need to fix the other qualities that are suitable for this machine. Those quality changes may still have
        # per-extruder settings in the container for the machine instead of the extruder.
        if machine_quality_changes.getId() not in ("empty", "empty_quality_changes"):
            quality_changes_machine_definition_id = machine_quality_changes.getDefinition().getId()
        else:
            whole_machine_definition = machine.definition
            machine_entry = machine.definition.getMetaDataEntry("machine")
            if machine_entry is not None:
                container_registry = ContainerRegistry.getInstance()
                whole_machine_definition = container_registry.findDefinitionContainers(id = machine_entry)[0]

            quality_changes_machine_definition_id = "fdmprinter"
            if whole_machine_definition.getMetaDataEntry("has_machine_quality"):
                quality_changes_machine_definition_id = machine.definition.getMetaDataEntry("quality_definition",
                                                                                            whole_machine_definition.getId())
        qcs = self.findInstanceContainers(type = "quality_changes", definition = quality_changes_machine_definition_id)
        qc_groups = {}  # map of qc names -> qc containers
        for qc in qcs:
            qc_name = qc.getName()
            if qc_name not in qc_groups:
                qc_groups[qc_name] = []
            qc_groups[qc_name].append(qc)
            # Try to find from the quality changes cura directory too
            quality_changes_container = self._findQualityChangesContainerInCuraFolder(machine_quality_changes.getName())
            if quality_changes_container:
                qc_groups[qc_name].append(quality_changes_container)

        for qc_name, qc_list in qc_groups.items():
            qc_dict = {"global": None, "extruders": []}
            for qc in qc_list:
                extruder_position = qc.getMetaDataEntry("position")
                if extruder_position is not None:
                    qc_dict["extruders"].append(qc)
                else:
                    qc_dict["global"] = qc
            if qc_dict["global"] is not None and len(qc_dict["extruders"]) == 1:
                # Move per-extruder settings
                for qc_setting_key in qc_dict["global"].getAllKeys():
                    settable_per_extruder = machine.getProperty(qc_setting_key, "settable_per_extruder")
                    if settable_per_extruder:
                        setting_value = qc_dict["global"].getProperty(qc_setting_key, "value")

                        setting_definition = machine.getSettingDefinition(qc_setting_key)
                        new_instance = SettingInstance(setting_definition, definition_changes)
                        new_instance.setProperty("value", setting_value)
                        new_instance.resetState()  # Ensure that the state is not seen as a user state.
                        qc_dict["extruders"][0].addInstance(new_instance)
                        qc_dict["extruders"][0].setDirty(True)

                        qc_dict["global"].removeInstance(qc_setting_key, postpone_emit=True)

        # Set next stack at the end
        extruder_stack.setNextStack(machine)

        return extruder_stack

    def _findQualityChangesContainerInCuraFolder(self, name: str) -> Optional[InstanceContainer]:
        quality_changes_dir = Resources.getPath(cura.CuraApplication.CuraApplication.ResourceTypes.QualityChangesInstanceContainer)

        instance_container = None

        for item in os.listdir(quality_changes_dir):
            file_path = os.path.join(quality_changes_dir, item)
            if not os.path.isfile(file_path):
                continue

            parser = configparser.ConfigParser(interpolation = None)
            try:
                parser.read([file_path])
            except Exception:
                # Skip, it is not a valid stack file
                continue

            if not parser.has_option("general", "name"):
                continue

            if parser["general"]["name"] == name:
                # Load the container
                container_id = os.path.basename(file_path).replace(".inst.cfg", "")
                if self.findInstanceContainers(id = container_id):
                    # This container is already in the registry, skip it
                    continue

                instance_container = InstanceContainer(container_id)
                with open(file_path, "r", encoding = "utf-8") as f:
                    serialized = f.read()
                try:
                    instance_container.deserialize(serialized, file_path)
                except ContainerFormatError:
                    Logger.logException("e", "Unable to deserialize InstanceContainer %s", file_path)
                    continue
                self.addContainer(instance_container)
                break

        return instance_container

    # Fix the extruders that were upgraded to ExtruderStack instances during addContainer.
    # The stacks are now responsible for setting the next stack on deserialize. However,
    # due to problems with loading order, some stacks may not have the proper next stack
    # set after upgrading, because the proper global stack was not yet loaded. This method
    # makes sure those extruders also get the right stack set.
    def _connectUpgradedExtruderStacksToMachines(self) -> None:
        extruder_stacks = self.findContainers(container_type = ExtruderStack.ExtruderStack)
        for extruder_stack in extruder_stacks:
            if extruder_stack.getNextStack():
                # Has the right next stack, so ignore it.
                continue

            machines = ContainerRegistry.getInstance().findContainerStacks(id = extruder_stack.getMetaDataEntry("machine", ""))
            if machines:
                extruder_stack.setNextStack(machines[0])
            else:
                Logger.log("w", "Could not find machine {machine} for extruder {extruder}", machine = extruder_stack.getMetaDataEntry("machine"), extruder = extruder_stack.getId())

    # Override just for the type.
    @classmethod
    @override(ContainerRegistry)
    def getInstance(cls, *args, **kwargs) -> "CuraContainerRegistry":
        return cast(CuraContainerRegistry, super().getInstance(*args, **kwargs))